Root beer has been an American classic for generations, with its rich, creamy taste that harkens back to the days of old-fashioned soda fountains and ice cream parlors. As countless variations have popped up over the years, each offering their own unique blend of sassafras, sarsaparilla, vanilla, and other secret ingredients—it can be hard to choose which brand to savor. But don’t you worry! Our test kitchen has conducted a rigorous taste test, and we are thrilled to share our top root beer picks that bubbled up to the top!

 A&W Root Beer

It should come as no surprise that A&W makes the list. Veterans in the root beer game, their recipe has delighted taste buds for years. When chilled just right, this root beer has a smooth and creamy texture that feels like a comforting hug after a long day. The vanilla notes are mellow and perfectly balanced with the sweet caramel body, leaving you wanting another sip as soon as the glass empties.

 Barq’s Root Beer

“Barq’s has bite!” isn’t just a catchy slogan—it’s a statement of fact. With a distinct sharpness that sets it apart from smoother contenders, Barq’s offers an effervescence and spiciness that make it ideal for those who enjoy an invigorating fizz and a peppery aftertaste. It pairs exceptionally well with savory snacks like salty pretzels or smoky barbecue.

 IBC Root Beer

If you’re searching for that old-school bottle experience, IBC will transport your senses to simpler times. This root beer boasts a robust flavor profile with undertones of licorice and hints of molasses. Its richness is coupled with just enough carbonation to keep it refreshing—not overwhelming—making it an ideal choice for those who appreciate depth in their beverage.

 Stewart’s Root Beer

Stewart’s Root Beer stands out due to its artisanal approach to a traditionally industrial product. Each sip delivers a homemade essence derived from its unique blend of herbs, berries, and spices. It has a subtle sweetness rounded off by an herby complexity that makes it fascinatingly moreish—the kind of root beer you might pair with more sophisticated fare or enjoy on its own in moments of quiet contemplation.

 Mug Root Beer

Mug brings forth a quintessential root beer experience with its foam-crested waves of nostalgic flavor. It’s milder than some others on our list but what it lacks in pizzazz it makes up for in smooth drinkability—think of cozy evenings watching fireflies dance on the porch swing.

No two palates are exactly alike when it comes to the nuanced world of root beer preferences—but our test kitchen aficionados agree: these five offerings provide a stellar cross-section of what this timeless beverage has to offer. Whether you’re looking for immense creaminess, biting spice, or homespun complexity, there’s a root beer on this list that will satisfy your craving for this frothy American treat. Cheers!