RaMell Ross’s “The Nickel Boys” attempts to capture the harrowing realities of a Florida reform school, the Nickel Academy, notorious for its brutality and abuse. Based on Colson Whitehead‘s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, the film aims to expose the systemic racism and cruelty that thrived in such institutions. Ross, however, struggles to maintain narrative focus, leaving the viewer with a disjointed and ultimately less impactful experience.

The film’s strength lies in its visual language. Ross employs stark black-and-white cinematography, mimicking the stark realities of the school’s environment. The brutality is conveyed through subtle yet powerful shots, showcasing the dehumanizing conditions and the boys’ desperate struggle for survival. The performances are equally impactful, with the young actors conveying the anguish and resilience of the victims.

However, Ross’s attempt to incorporate various perspectives and storylines within a limited runtime results in a scattered narrative. The film jumps between the experiences of different boys, each with their own traumas and struggles. While this offers glimpses into the diverse realities of the school, it ultimately dilutes the emotional impact. The lack of a clear central protagonist and a defined arc leaves the audience feeling somewhat lost and disconnected.

“The Nickel Boys” undeniably succeeds in its mission to expose the horrors of the reform school system. However, the film’s attempt to encompass too much within its narrative scope ultimately hinders its effectiveness. While the powerful visuals and performances resonate, the fragmented plot and lack of a central character arc prevent the film from fully reaching its potential. Ultimately, “The Nickel Boys” leaves a lasting impression, but not the deeply resonant one it could have been with a tighter focus.