Chicken nuggets are a staple in many households, especially if there are kids involved. But not all chicken nuggets are created equal, and when it comes to a discerning young palate, only the best will do. We sat down with Jamie, an opinionated 11-year-old nugget connoisseur, to determine the ultimate chicken nugget that can please even the pickiest of eaters.

First and foremost, texture is key. Jamie states that the perfect nugget must have a crispy exterior that crunches audibly when you bite into it. Sogginess is a deal-breaker. But it’s not just about the crunch; the interior needs to be tender but not mushy, with real chicken texture that you can see and feel.

Flavor is another crucial factor in nugget assessment. According to Jamie, a top-tier nugget should taste like chicken—not just breading or seasoning—and shouldn’t need dipping sauce to taste good. However, when it comes to sauces, our expert prefers a classic ketchup or barbecue sauce but insists they should complement rather than mask the flavor of the chicken.

Jamie ran an extensive tasting of various brands and declared that store-bought frozen varieties just don’t make the cut compared to fast-food offerings. After much deliberation and several tasting sessions, Jamie’s top pick for the best chicken nuggets comes from none other than Chick-fil-A. The reasons? They’re consistently crispy on the outside, moist and flavorful on the inside, and the distinct shape of each piece lets you know you’re eating actual chicken.

A close second is McDonald’s McNuggets for their unparalleled crunch and nostalgic taste profile which appeals to both kids and adults alike.

In conclusion, according to Jamie, if you’re looking for something that’ll meet the high standards of young food critics at home, Chick-fil-A nuggets are your best bet but keep some McNuggets in reach for those days when you need an extra crunch in your life.