The 10 best ‘Sherlock Holmes’ adaptations of all time, ranked
Sherlock Holmes, the iconic detective created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, has been adapted countless times across various media platforms. From stage to screen, the character has evolved with time while keeping the essence of his brilliant deductive skills and adventures. Here’s a look at ten of the best adaptations that have left their mark on audiences and critics alike.
1. Jeremy Brett in ‘Sherlock Holmes’ (Granada series) – Jeremy Brett’s portrayal is often considered the definitive on-screen representation of Sherlock Holmes. His meticulous attention to detail and psychological depth has set the bar very high for all subsequent adaptations.
2. Benedict Cumberbatch in ‘Sherlock’ (BBC series) – Modernizing Sherlock Holmes for contemporary audiences, Benedict Cumberbatch brought a unique charm and intellectual prowess to the role in this critically acclaimed series.
3. Basil Rathbone in ‘Sherlock Holmes’ Films (1939-1946) – Starring in 14 films as the titular detective, Basil Rathbone’s sharp wit and classic portrayal made his version everlasting for many fans.
4. Robert Downey Jr. in ‘Sherlock Holmes’ (2009) and ‘Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows’ (2011) – Robert Downey Jr.’s charismatic yet unconventional interpretation brought an action-oriented twist to Sherlock Holmes’ character.
5. Jonny Lee Miller in ‘Elementary’ – This American TV adaptation placed Sherlock in New York City with Lucy Liu’s Joan Watson by his side. Miller’s performance received praise for its originality and fresh take on addiction issues that plague the genius detective.
6. Peter Cushing in ‘The Hound of the Baskervilles’ (1959) and BBC series – Peter Cushing captured both the intellectual and aristocratic facets of Holmes with great conviction across several movies and a BBC television series.
7. Ian McKellen in ‘Mr. Holmes’ (2015) – Ian McKellen presented a nuanced portrayal of an aging Sherlock struggling with memory loss while still pursuing unsolved cases, adding emotional depth to the legendary detective.
8. Douglas Wilmer in BBC series (1964-1965) – Not as well-known as some others on this list, Douglas Wilmer’s performance is considered highly faithful to Conan Doyle’s description and beloved by purists for his scholarly approach to solving mysteries.
9. Vasily Livanov in ‘The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson’ (1979-1986) – Livanov’s portrayal was so lauded in Russia that he was even honored by Queen Elizabeth II for it; his work embodies a timeless quality that captures hearts internationally.
10. Christopher Plummer in ‘Murder by Decree’ (1979) and ‘Silver Blaze’ (TV, 1977) – Christopher Plummer’s elegant interpretation combined with his stage presence added gravitas to the role of Sherlock Holmes.
These adaptations have each contributed something special to the enduring legacy of Sherlock Holmes, showcasing how a character can be reinvented time and again while staying true to his roots as literature’s favorite detective.