When discussing the Internet sensation that is Critical Role, a live-streamed Dungeons and Dragons game, it’s almost impossible not to delve into the characters portrayed by the talented cast members. Each cast member brings a unique flair to their roles, leading to memorable performances that have resonated with fans worldwide. Here are some of the best characters brought to life by the Critical Role cast.

Matthew Mercer (Dungeon Master) – The omnipresent narrator and creator of worlds, Matthew Mercer, doesn’t play a single character but rather an entire cosmos of them. While he’s not a player character, some of his most memorable creations include the cunning crime lord The Gentleman, the mysterious and powerful Artagan, and of course, everyone’s favorite arcane shopkeeper, Gilmore.

Laura Bailey as Vex’ahlia – A cunning half-elf ranger with a sharp wit and even sharper arrows, Vex’ahlia “Vex” de Rolo became a fan-favorite for her complex backstory and growth from a treasure-driven huntress to a caring and noble hero. Accompanied by her bear companion Trinket, Laura Bailey’s Vex is remembered fondly for her shrewd negotiation skills and heartfelt moments.

Liam O’Brien as Caleb Widogast – A human wizard haunted by his past, Caleb Widogast’s journey of redemption and search for knowledge is one of the most compelling narratives in Critical Role’s second campaign. Liam O’Brien portrays Caleb with an intense depth that captures his complex emotions and drive for atonement.

Travis Willingham as Grog Strongjaw – As a goliath barbarian with an infectious laugh and simple view on life, Grog Strongjaw stole hearts as much with his might as with his innocence. Travis Willingham’s portrayal of Grog provided comic relief while also showcasing moments of surprising wisdom and vulnerability.

Marisha Ray as Keyleth – A druid on a rite-of-passage journey to become the leader of her people, Marisha Ray’s Keyleth evolved from an awkward young half-elf into a powerful voice for change and balance. Her emotional arc struck chords with many watchers who got to see Keyleth’s trials and triumphs mirrored in their own lives.

Sam Riegel as Scanlan Shorthalt – A gnome bard who uses music and mischief to overcome challenges, Sam Riegel’s Scanlan is best known for his quick thinking, catchy songs, heartfelt moments, and irreverent humor. Despite his often comical demeanor, Scanlan’s depth was ultimately revealed in personal struggles that won over fans.

Taliesin Jaffe as Percival de Rolo III – With a sharp mind and an even sharper tongue, Percival “Percy” Fredrickstein Von Musel Klossowski de Rolo III is Taliesin Jaffe’s brooding human gunslinger plagued by vengeance. Percy’s intricate backstory and moral dilemmas added layers of intrigue to the group dynamics.

Ashley Johnson as Pike Trickfoot – A gnome cleric full of compassion who serves as the team’s moral compass; Ashley Johnson’s Pike Trickfoot showed that strength comes in many forms—not least through faith and healing. Her kindness coupled with badassery makes Pike unforgettable in fan discussions.

Each member of Critical Role has brought life to numerous characters over their multiple campaigns providing rich narratives filled with laughter, sorrow, combat, and camaraderie. The characters listed here are just the tip of the iceberg among many nuanced performances throughout their ongoing saga. These heroes represent the best in character crafting—multilayered individuals who have not only grown within their fictional world but also within the hearts and minds of viewers around the globe.