Apple’s newest headquarters, the Apple Park, has been making headlines since its construction began nearly a decade ago. Designed by the renowned architect Norman Foster, the campus spans over 2.8 million square feet and can accommodate up to 12,000 employees.

One of the most captivating features of the Apple Park is the Dynamic Island – an artificial hill that covers four stories beneath the campus. The hill, which measures 30 feet tall and 165 feet in diameter, is covered in over 9,000 trees and is designed to be a unique landmark and a green space for employees.

While the Dynamic Island is undeniably stunning and innovative, some critics have argued that it prioritizes form over function. In other words, the hill may look impressive, but it does not serve a practical purpose for Apple or its employees.

One of the primary concerns is the cost of building and maintaining the Dynamic Island. It is estimated that the hill cost $161 million to construct and requires significant resources to maintain the trees and other vegetation. In a practical sense, this investment could have been used to develop more functional spaces for employees or to fund research and development of new products.

Another criticism of the Dynamic Island is that it disrupts the natural environment. Apple’s decision to bulldoze acres of land to construct an artificial hill has raised concerns about the environmental impact. Despite the fact that the hill is covered with trees, its creation required significant excavation and grading of the land. This has led to questions about whether Apple could have found a more sustainable and environmentally friendly way to create a unique landmark for its headquarters.

Finally, there is some debate about whether the Dynamic Island is a practical space for employees. While the hill is undoubtedly impressive and visually appealing, some have raised questions about whether it is a functional space for employees. The steep incline and lack of accessibility make it difficult for employees to navigate, particularly for those with disabilities or mobility issues. Additionally, the hill is not conducive to large gatherings or events, as the sloping terrain makes it difficult to set up furniture or equipment.