Who Did It Best? Doctor Who’s Best Doctors, Ranked

“Doctor Who” has been an iconic part of British television since it first aired in 1963. Over the years, thirteen actors have officially taken on the role of the Doctor, bringing their own unique take to this enigmatic time-traveling character. While each actor’s portrayal is special in its own right, fans often debate about which Doctor stands out above the rest. Here’s a look at some of the best Doctors, ranked according to their impact, popularity, and contribution to the legacy of the show.
1. David Tennant (Tenth Doctor): Widely adored by fans, Tennant’s time as the Doctor was marked by charm, energy, and emotional depth. His tenure included some of the show’s most memorable episodes and story arcs.
2. Tom Baker (Fourth Doctor): Known for his eccentric style and long scarf, Baker’s portrayal is one of the most iconic, with his whimsical yet authoritative performance defining the character for a whole generation.
3. Matt Smith (Eleventh Doctor): Smith brought youthfulness and an old soul to the Eleventh Doctor. His tenure saw a balance of whimsy and darkness, leaving a lasting impression with his heartfelt performances.
4. Peter Capaldi (Twelfth Doctor): Bringing a more serious and contemplative approach to the character, Capaldi’s portrayal is praised for its depth and complexity while respecting the long history of the show.
5. Jon Pertwee (Third Doctor):Pertwee’s time as the Doctor was notable for introducing several significant elements in “Doctor Who” lore and a more action-oriented approach to the character.
6. Christopher Eccleston (Ninth Doctor): Although only part of one series, Eccleston’s interpretation was crucial for revitalizing “Doctor Who” for modern audiences with his more grounded and intense portrayal.
7. Patrick Troughton (Second Doctor): Succeeding William Hartnell was no small feat, but Troughton’s impish charm and wit made for a distinct and endearing incarnation that shaped much of what followed.
8. Jodie Whittaker (Thirteenth Doctor): As the first woman to play the role, Whittaker’s historic casting brought a fresh dynamic to the series with her performance mixing boundless enthusiasm with emotional authenticity.
9. William Hartnell (First Doctor): The original portrayer of the role laid down many characteristics that would define the Doctor: brilliance, unpredictability, and a touch of irascibility.
10. Sylvester McCoy (Seventh Doctor): McCoy’s era started off light but evolved into darker storylines where his performance revealed layers of mystery and intrigue.
11. Paul McGann (Eighth Doctor): While he only appeared in one television film (!996), McGann’s portrayal has been expanded in audio dramas. His brief screen time showed promise with a charismatic & romantic interpretation.
12. Peter Davison (Fifth Doctor): Taking over from Tom Baker was challenging, but Davison brought vulnerability and humanity to his youthful portrayal that resonated with many fans.
13. Colin Baker (Sixth Doctor): While his tenure was tumultuous due to factors outside his control, including script quality and an 18-month hiatus imposed by BBC, Baker presented an arrogant yet colorful depiction of the Time Lord.
Ranking is subjective – every fan has their favorite Doctors for different reasons – these rankings do not diminish any of these actors’ performances or contributions; they merely offer one perspective on an enduring legacy that continues to evolve.