As holiday cheer fills the air, there’s one creamy, spiced beverage that always seems to stir up a nostalgic zest: eggnog. While some prefer to make it from scratch, plenty of folks turn to store-bought brands for convenience and consistent quality. After tapping into a multitude of reader opinions, here are the top store-bought eggnog brands that you might want to consider adding to your holiday shopping list.

1. Southern Comfort Traditional Eggnog

Long known for their whiskey, Southern Comfort brings a non-alcoholic version of eggnog that has been a hit among fans. Its smooth texture and perfect blend of spices have earned it a place in many refrigerators across the country.

2. Horizon Organic Low Fat Eggnog

For those who are health-conscious but still want to indulge in the festive spirit, Horizon Organic’s low-fat eggnog offers a guilt-free alternative. It’s not only lighter on calories but also maintains the rich flavor that eggnog is known for.

3. Califia Farms Holiday Nog Almond Milk

Vegans rejoice! Califia Farms presents an egg-free and dairy-free nog made from almond milk that doesn’t skimp on taste. People appreciate it for its creamy consistency and environmentally friendly packaging.

4. Borden Classic Eggnog

A staple in many households, Borden’s eggnog is beloved for its classic flavor profile that embodies just the right amount of sweetness and spice. It makes for a great base in mixed drinks or enjoyed as is.

5. Pennsylvania Dutch Eggnog

For those who prefer an alcoholic twist, Pennsylvania Dutch offers an eggnog with real dairy cream, blended whiskey, rum, and brandy already mixed in. It’s a convenient and delicious way to bring some extra warmth to your holiday festivities.

6. Trader Joe’s Light Eggnog

Trader Joe’s throws its hat into the ring with a lighter version of this traditional drink. It cuts through the heaviness while retaining the creamy goodness, hitting all the right notes with cinnamon and nutmeg.

7. Hood Golden Eggnog

An East Coast favorite, Hood’s Golden Eggnog garners praise for its thick consistency and flavorful blend. It’s especially popular among those who favor a more custard-like texture in their eggnog.

While each brand brings something unique to the table, they all share one common trait: the power to bring smiles and spread joy during the holidays. Whether you prefer your nog spiked, lightened up or vegan-friendly, this list has something for everyone looking to sip on some seasonal delight. So next time you’re at the store pondering over which carton of eggnog to bring home, consider these reader favorites—they just might become part of your own holiday tradition.