As the popularity of podcasts continues to grow, so does the variety of genres available for listeners to choose from. Among the most engaging and suspenseful forms of storytelling is the mystery genre. From true crime to fictional whodunnits, mystery podcasts keep audiences hooked with gripping narratives, intricate plot twists, and captivating characters.

To help you navigate this vast and ever-expanding podcast universe, we’ve rounded up the best mystery podcasts of 2023. These shows are guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat, guessing until the very end.

1. Serial

Starting with an obvious choice, Serial is one of the most popular true-crime podcasts of all time, garnering widespread acclaim for its groundbreaking first season. The show uses investigative journalism to examine a single case each season, digging into the details of each case and unraveling the truth behind the crime.

2. My Favorite Murder

For fans of true crime, My Favorite Murder is a must-listen. Hosted by comedians Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, the show takes an irreverent approach to the genre, discussing their favorite murder cases and cracking jokes along the way.

3. Limetown

Limetown is an audio drama that tells the story of a journalist investigating the mysterious disappearance of over 300 people from a small, secluded town. Through captivating storytelling, the show manages to create an immersive and eerie atmosphere that will keep you hooked from start to finish.

4. The Black Tapes

The Black Tapes is a fictional podcast that follows a journalist as she investigates supernatural occurrences and strange occurrences. The show is heavily influenced by shows like The X-Files and is full of suspense, intrigue, and creepy moments.

5. The Magnus Archives

The Magnus Archives is another fictional podcast that tells stand-alone horror stories with a unique framing device – all of the stories are recorded statements from people recounting supernatural experiences they’ve had. Each episode is creepy and atmospheric, and the overarching story that emerges is just as intriguing.

6. Criminal

Criminal is a true-crime podcast with a twist – rather than focusing solely on the crimes themselves, the show delves into the human stories behind them. From the perspective of victims, perpetrators, and those caught in the crossfire, Criminal explores the complex and often messy nature of crime and punishment.

7. Casefile

Casefile is another true-crime podcast, but with a more serious and sober tone. Hosted by an anonymous Australian narrator, the show delves into some of the most chilling and twisted criminal cases in recent history, detailing the police investigations, trials, and ultimately, the outcomes of each case.

Whether you’re a fan of true-crime or fictional horror, there’s no shortage of mystery podcasts to choose from. These shows have set the bar high for storytelling, immersing listeners in suspenseful narratives that will keep you guessing until the very end.